Iraq and the Islamic World

You are currently browsing the archive for the Iraq and the Islamic World category.

If you haven’t seen the WikiLeaks video of the Apache helicopter attack, it’s pretty damning. Two helicopters engage a group of eight men, one of whom appears to be armed but none of whom appears hostile. All were killed. Two of the dead turned out to be Reuters staff, armed only with cameras. Two children and their father were also shot in the attack.

One the “related videos” are a half dozen videos purporting to show American soldiers killing civilians. I honestly don’t know what to make of them– but the WikiLeaks video has been verified as authentic.

In this video, Ethan McCord recounts his arrival at the aftermath of a shooting of civilians in Iraq by an Apache helicopter. He tells of his effort to save two children, and of his commander’s order to “quit worrying about the kids” and get back on patrol.

He also tells of his grave error: going against Army training and permitting his humanity to show through.

Melophores by dynamosquito.
(Dynamosquito image.)

Earlier this week, the host of KUER’s “Radio West” interviewed Robert Baer, former CIA field officer, about Iran.  Baer’s view: our country doesn’t really understand what makes Iran tick.  They are not religious fanatics, they are a military dictatorship bent on one thing only: security.  That means (to them) dominating the Persian Gulf region and having more control over the price of oil, which is their main source of income.

Becausde we don’t understand them, the Iranians are largely outmaneuvering us politically.  Iran is a regional superpower, and they’re playing us to get what they want.  And sanctions won;t work, because they don’t think in terms of short-term results.

One of my principles of conflict analysis is that to understand why a participant does what they do, we have to know what they want.  This interview is worth a listen.

Tags: ,

Our family Thanksgiving dinner this year included my parents, all their children, two of their grandchildren, and some in-laws– along with five Iraqi refugees my sister-in-law has become involved with through her community volunteer work.  Two are Iraqi women, and they brought their children, aged 10, 5, and 2.  One woman and her two young kids arrived by way of Jordan 11 months ago, the other and her son have been here 8 months.  (In order to avoid making their transition even more difficult, I’ll avoid using their real names.)

While their current living situation is clearly more secure than life in Baghdad, their integration into New England life has not been easy.  The weather, while completely different from the hot desert climate they come from, is not their most difficult challenge. 

Danez is trained as a network technician; she’s got a certificate from a school in Baghdad and several years of experience.   My brother and sister-in-law helped her format her Curriculum Vitae as an American-style resume.  But here in New Hampshire, prospective employers hire American-born candidates who are far less qualified.  Danez never even gets called, much less interviewed.  Apparently, employers are reluctant to consider a candidate whose name they can’t pronounce– or else they really do think all Middle Eastern people are terrorists. 

Both women currently work at Wal-Mart, for wages that won’t pay their rent once their federal assistance runs out.

Danez’s son Ali is in the sixth grade.  His English is limited, and he doesn’t yet understand how American children interact.  Worse, he’s small for his age, and he gets tormented by some of the kids– American and otherwise– who call him “terrorist.”  One told his teacher that Ali planned to blow up the school.  And his teacher believed it.  Several times, Ali has been caught in a he-said-she-said situation with a group of African refugees.  His teachers believe the Africans without question.  Ali recently got kicked off the bus because a Somali kid told the teacher Ali called him a racial name.  However, Ali doesn’t know any racial names.  One of the African kids called him “white boy,” and he had to ask us what it meant.

Danez had a driver’s license in Iraq, so she went for her driver’s test here.  She passed the written exam with no problem, but flunked the driving part.  Three times.  In this state, that means she can’t test again without a hearing.  She had her hearing last week, and the results of the test were produced as evidence: in the third test, she’d done everything right, but then made a left turn in a manner the instructor considered unsafe.  That one error caused her to fail.  (Her driving test was much more involved than those of some American-born kids we know who recently got their licenses, and who passed despite a number of errors.)

For Thanksgiving, my sister-in-law drove out to pick up the women and their children.  They joined us for their first Thanksgiving meal.  Interestingly, when told of the origin of the holiday, they asked, “Didn’t Americans and Indians fight each other?”  That came later, I explain, after the elder leaders (Edward Winslow of the Pilgrims and Massasoit of the Wampanoag) died.  “Is there a fast before Thanksgiving, like our Ramadan?”  Not today, but the settlers who began the tradition had been starving, and half of them died during the first winter.

I watched our Iraqi guests taste with interest the roast turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin pie– all foods they appeared unfamiliar with.  We compared spice names– hech we identified as cardamom.  And my sister stepped in to care for the Turkmeni-speaking two-year-old, proving once again that a child is a child in any language.

This is a bad economy for anyone looking for a job.  But to see a qualified technician working at Wal-Mart because prospective employers don’t like her name– that I find very troubling.  Especially since the Iraqis are supposed to be our allies.


(AFP photo.)

“What has been clear throughout this process is that until we have a political reconciliation and stabilization, that we are going to continue to have problems in Iraq. And the fact that this deployment — redeployment — is small and isn’t taking place for five months, the bulk of it, I think indicates the degree to which the central problem still has not been solved.” –Sen. Barack Obama.

General Petraeus has been saying for over a year that there is no military solution in Iraq.  Other military comnmanders have said so.  Yet the Bush administration and Sen. John McCain (at least in public) insist that the solution to Iraq is military.

Maybe, just maybe, Senator Obama gets it: peace in Iraq cannot come from the barrel of a gun.  It’s got to come from the hard work of reconciliation and nationbuilding.



A reader writes:

The video above comes from CBS News, titled ”The Iraq War’s Fallen” When the video counter gets around 00:45  this information is shown:

98% Male
75% White
Most common age:21

This report says that 4,000 have died in this war. My question is, do you think it matters what sex or color they are? CBS also points out a couple cities/states that have lost the most people in the war. They didn’t mention if these places had the largest number that went to Iraq.  The largest number of people sent from one place would probably also have the largest number of people killed.  If CBS wants to give those kind of statistics then they should give all of them.

2% female = 80 women died 
25% of some other color = 1,000 people of color died.

To me, it doesn’t matter what sex, what race, or where they are from: 4,000 PEOPLE died.  That is the real news and it is sad.

I agree.  The press goes to great lengths to obscure the realities of war.

As one who loves statistics, it is interesting to note that the U.S. population is 66% non-Hispanic white (including Middle Eastern).  Whether it means anything that whites have died in higher percentage than their percentage of population I am not prepared to speculate.  The fact is, 4,000 Americans have died in the war, and the death toll among Iraqis (military and civilian) has been far, far higher– not to mention those of other countries, both our allies and our enemies.

“Afghanistan stands at a crossroads.  The progress achieved after six years of international engagement is under serious threat from resurgent violence, weakening international resolve, mounting regional challenges and a growing lack of confidence on the part of the Afghan people about the future direction of their country.”

Quoted from a U.S.-commissioned study that BBC says warns that Afghanistan risks becoming a failed state. Here’s the strange part: BBC quotes AP as its source, but I have so far been unable to find an AP report on the matter. It definitely wasn’t on the AP World page this morning.  More selective reporting?

Omar Osama bin Laden, right, and his British wife Jane Felix-Brown, ...
AP photo

“I don’t want to be in that situation to just fight. I like to find another way and this other way may be like we do now, talking.”

So says Omar Osama bin Laden, son of the Al Queda leader, who hopes to negotiate a truce between Al Queda and the West. He notes that his father was a Western ally when he fought the Russians in Afghanistan.

“Referring to what he called ‘asymmetric war techniques’ – the practice of attacking a more powerful enemy’s weak spots – India’s security adviser [M. K. Narayanan] said the region faced a new paradigm of al-Qaeda-inspired terrorism through its extensive network of planning, funding, training and arms supply. The training schools, he said, were turning out a new international brigade of terrorists.”

So now Al-Queda has franchised new terrorist groups… and we’ve got more enemies than ever before. Are we winning the so-called War on Terror? Maybe we need to review what constitutes a win.
Maintaining contacts with the other side pays off: Afghan President Hamid Karzai says he’s getting several contacts from Taliban leaders each week seeking peace.

I’m always baffled by governments’ refusal to talk to the other side, as with the U.S. and Sri Lanka. There are only two ways to make peace. One is to wipe out the other side and all of its supporters: in a word, genocide.  The other is to develop a framework in which the needs of both sides can be met– and as Afghanistan shows, communication is the only precondition.

Whether Karzai can make peace remains to be seen.  But its a given that, in post-modern war, peace cannot be obtained without talking to “the enemy.”

« Older entries